1. Guides
  2. Why Is My Cigar Falling Apart: Causes and Solutions Explained

Why Is My Cigar Falling Apart: Causes and Solutions Explained

Why Is My Cigar Falling Apart

Why Is My Cigar Falling Apart: Causes and Solutions Explained

If you’re a cigar enthusiast, you’ve likely experienced the disappointment of having a cigar fall apart while you’re enjoying it. This frustrating occurrence can make it difficult to relax and savor the experience. In this article, we will discuss the possible reasons behind this issue and offer some solutions to help prevent it from happening again.

Several factors can contribute to a cigar falling apart, ranging from improper handling and cutting techniques to the overall quality of the cigar. Additionally, environmental factors, such as humidity and temperature, can play a role in the deterioration of a cigar. It’s important to understand the various factors involved to effectively age and maintain your cigars, ensuring that they remain intact and enjoyable to smoke.

Key Takeaways

  • Understand the various factors contributing to a cigar falling apart
  • Proper handling and cutting techniques can help prevent deterioration
  • Environmental factors and proper maintenance play a crucial role in cigar preservation

Common Causes of Cigar Deterioration

Humidity Issues

One of the most common reasons for a cigar falling apart is humidity issues. Cigars need to be stored at a specific humidity level to maintain their optimal condition. Ideally, the humidity should be between 68% and 72%. If the humidity is too low, the cigar can become dry and brittle, causing the wrapper to crack or flake. On the other hand, if the humidity is too high, the cigar can become too moist, leading to mold growth or an uneven burn. It is essential to have a well-maintained humidor to ensure proper humidity levels for your cigars.

Temperature Fluctuations

Another factor that can cause cigars to deteriorate is temperature fluctuations. Cigars should ideally be stored at a stable temperature around 65°F to ensure optimal conditions. Sudden temperature changes can lead to the expansion or contraction of the cigar’s tobacco, causing the wrapper to split or come apart. Also, high temperatures can promote the growth of tobacco beetles, which can damage your cigars. Make sure your cigars are stored in a cool, dark place to minimize the impact of temperature fluctuations.

Improper Storage

Lastly, improper storage can significantly contribute to a cigar falling apart. Cigars must be protected from physical damage, as well as exposure to air, light, and extreme temperature changes. When transporting cigars, it is vital to keep them in a protective casing or use cellophane to prevent damage to the wrapper. Additionally, using a dull cutter or cutting the cigar improperly can result in the wrapper unraveling or cracking. Always ensure that your cigars are adequately stored and handled with care to prevent deterioration. More information on proper cigar storage and handling can be found here.

Handling and Cutting Techniques

Cutting Errors

One common reason for a cigar falling apart is improper cutting techniques. To properly cut a cigar, it is crucial to use a sharp and appropriate cutter, such as a guillotine cutter or cigar scissors. A dull cutter can cause the wrapper to tear, which can lead to the cigar unraveling. Additionally, avoid cutting too low or too high; instead, aim for just above the cigar’s cap line. It is essential to make a clean and decisive cut to ensure a successful smoking experience. Here’s a quick guide on how to cut a cigar properly.

Incorrect Lighting

Another factor that contributes to a cigar falling apart is incorrect lighting. Lighting a cigar improperly can cause an uneven burn, which might lead to the wrapper and filler burning at different rates, resulting in the cigar unraveling. To correctly light a cigar:

  1. Toast the cigar’s foot using a soft-flame lighter or a butane torch lighter.
  2. Hold the cigar at a 45-degree angle, with the flame about an inch below the foot.
  3. Slowly rotate the cigar while ensuring the flame evenly heats the entire foot.

Once the foot of the cigar is evenly toasted and begins to glow, it is ready to be smoked. Patience is the key to proper cigar lighting; avoid using accelerants such as lighter fluid, as they can affect the cigar’s taste negatively.


Lastly, overhandling a cigar can also lead to it falling apart. When smoking cigars, it’s essential to handle them gently, as excessive touching or rolling between your fingers can cause the wrapper to weaken or become damaged. To prevent overhandling, follow these simple tips:

  • Hold the cigar between your index finger and thumb, avoiding excessive pressure.
  • Do not roll the cigar between your fingers.
  • Avoid removing the band too early; wait until the cigar has warmed up and the band is loose to prevent the wrapper from tearing.

By paying attention to these handling and cutting techniques, we can ensure a pleasurable and problem-free cigar-smoking experience.

Quality of the Cigar

Construction Flaws

A properly constructed cigar is essential for an enjoyable smoking experience. However, construction flaws can negatively impact the performance and cause a cigar to fall apart. Common issues include an unraveling wrapper and cracked wrappers. To avoid these issues, it’s crucial to inspect your cigars carefully before purchasing. Look for:

  • Evenly rolled cigars with no visible wrinkles or gaps in the wrapper
  • Consistent firmness throughout the cigar
  • A well-cut cap

In addition to these visual checks, it’s also a good idea to gently roll the cigar between your fingers and listen for any crackling sound, which may indicate that the cigar is too dry.

Tobacco Quality

The quality of the tobacco used in a cigar can also have a significant impact on its performance and overall experience. High-quality tobacco will provide a consistent and pleasant flavor, whereas low-quality tobacco can cause a cigar to burn unevenly or have an unpleasant taste. There are a few factors that contribute to the quality of the tobacco:

  • Growing conditions: Ideal weather, soil, and climate conditions are necessary to produce top-quality tobacco.
  • Age of tobacco: Aging tobacco can enhance its flavors and improve its burn characteristics.
  • Fermentation process: Proper fermentation ensures that the tobacco leaves are free of ammonia and other impurities that can affect the taste and aroma of your cigar.

To enjoy a premium smoking experience, it’s essential to invest in cigars that use high-quality tobacco. Doing some research on the brand and the specific blend can help you make an informed decision. You can also consult with knowledgeable tobacconists who can recommend cigars known for their excellent tobacco quality and construction.

Environmental Factors

Exposure to Elements

Cigars can fall apart due to various environmental factors. One of the most common reasons is exposure to elements like humidity and temperature. Cigars are hygroscopic, which means they absorb moisture in a humid space and dry out quickly when exposed to dry conditions source. It is crucial to maintain proper humidity and temperature levels to ensure that the cigars do not fall apart. Ideally, the humidity level should be around 70%, and the temperature should be controlled between 68-72°F source.

  • Humidity: When a cigar is over-humidified, its filler tends to expand, causing stress to the wrapper that holds it together. This may result in the unraveling of the cigar wrapper source.
  • Temperature: High temperatures can encourage the growth of cigar beetles and mold, which can cause severe damage to cigars. Cigar beetles’ eggs start hatching at temperatures above 77°F (25°C) and humidity levels above 75%; this can affect the entire cigar collection source.

Physical Damage

Another factor that may cause cigars to fall apart is physical damage. This can happen due to mishandling, improper storage, or transportation. To avoid physical damage, it is essential to follow appropriate care and handling procedures, such as:

  1. Store cigars in a humidor to maintain the right humidity and temperature levels.
  2. Handle cigars gently to prevent external damage to their wrappers.
  3. Use a sharp, clean cutter for cutting the cigar cap to avoid tearing the wrapper.
  4. Before lighting, moisten the cap to reduce the possibility of cracks and splits.
  5. Avoid crushing cigars inside pockets or containers.

In conclusion, environmental factors like exposure to elements and physical damage significantly contribute to cigars falling apart. Taking adequate steps to maintain proper storage conditions, handling cigars carefully, and paying attention to humidity and temperature levels will help mitigate these issues and ensure that your cigars remain intact.

Cigar Aging and Maintenance

Aging Process

The aging process has a significant impact on the quality and enjoyment of your cigars. Proper aging ensures that the tobacco flavors meld together, resulting in a smoother and more complex taste experience. Ideally, cigars should be aged at a temperature between 65°F and 70°F (18°C and 21°C) with a relative humidity (RH) of 65-72% 1. Maintaining stable humidity levels is crucial as too much or too little humidity can cause the cigars to dry out or become moldy 2.

According to experts, many aficionados prefer to store their cigars at 63-65% RH and 63-65 degrees Fahrenheit as opposed to the traditional 70/70 levels, as it promotes better aging 3. However, it’s essential to find the ideal aging conditions tailored to your cigar collection, ensuring optimal flavor development and preservation.

Rotation and Maintenance

In addition to proper aging, it’s vital to regularly rotate your cigars and maintain your humidor for optimal results. Regularly rotating your cigars within the humidor ensures even humidity distribution and prevents the formation of mold or mildew on your precious collection 4. Keep in mind that a constantly fluctuating environment can be quite disastrous for your cigars, as it impedes the aging process 5.

Another essential aspect of maintenance is to fix any potential issues with your cigars, such as unraveling wrappers. While a cigar with extremely damaged wrappers might be beyond repair, applying pectin or roller’s glue to an isolated spot can save it from falling apart 6.

In conclusion, ensuring proper cigar aging and maintenance through appropriate temperature, humidity, and rotation is crucial to preserving your cigars’ quality and preventing them from falling apart.

Frequently Asked Questions

What causes a cigar wrapper to split while smoking?

Several reasons can cause a cigar wrapper to split while smoking. One common cause is the cigar being exposed to a fluctuating environment where the humidity level varies significantly. This can cause the wrapper to dry out and become brittle, eventually leading to cracks. It’s important to keep your cigars stored in a stable environment with proper humidity levels to avoid this issue.

Is it possible to smoke a cigar that has cracked?

It is possible to smoke a cigar with a cracked wrapper, but the experience might not be as enjoyable. The cracks may result in a suboptimal burn, causing uneven heating and affecting the overall taste. In some cases, we recommend using a cigar repair glue to fix minor cracks before smoking. However, if the damage is too severe, it might be best to avoid smoking that particular cigar.

How can tunneling in cigars be prevented?

Tunneling occurs when the inside of the cigar burns faster than the wrapper, causing an uneven burn. To prevent tunneling, ensure that the cigar is evenly lit and consistently rotate the cigar while smoking. It’s also important to regulate the pace of your smoking, avoiding smoking too fast or too slow. Taking the time to let the cigar cool down for a minute or two before resuming smoking can also help prevent tunneling.

What are the signs of an over-humidified cigar?

Over-humidified cigars can exhibit several signs, such as a soft and spongy texture or difficulty in lighting and maintaining a consistent burn. Over-humidification can also lead to mold and musty odors, which can affect the flavor of the cigar. To remedy this issue, check and adjust the humidity levels in your humidor to ensure optimal storage conditions.

How do you fix a peeling cigar wrapper?

If your cigar wrapper is peeling, it’s important to handle the cigar gently to avoid causing further damage. You can try to fix the peeling by carefully re-wrapping the loose portion of the wrapper around the cigar and securing it with a small amount of cigar repair glue or other adhesive options available in the market. Once the glue has set, the cigar should be safe to smoke.

Why do some cigars get soft and lose their firmness during smoking?

Cigars can lose their firmness during smoking due to a combination of factors like high humidity levels, too much saliva while smoking, and poor construction quality. Remember to store your cigars in a well-maintained humidor, and ensure that you’re not over-saturating the cigar with saliva while smoking. Additionally, consider choosing higher quality cigars to minimize the chances of this issue occurring.


Recent posts